Skip to main content

Major gifts play a crucial role in the financial health and impact of nonprofit organizations. They allow nonprofits to launch significant initiatives, expand their programs, or build their endowments, shaping the course of their work in profound ways. Developing a major gifts program can have a transformative effect on a nonprofit. It can lead to increased revenue, donor engagement, and organizational visibility, strengthening the organization’s ability to fulfill its mission.

This post will provide a comprehensive guide to building a successful major gifts program, exploring key elements such as defining major gifts, identifying and cultivating prospects, making the ask, donor stewardship, staff training, program evaluation, and more.

What are Major Gifts?

Major gifts are monumental financial contributions that can significantly propel a nonprofit towards achieving its mission. Unlike occasional smaller gifts, these generous contributions stem from a deep-rooted relationship and prolonged cultivation between the donor and the nonprofit. Such immense potential makes developing a major gifts program a linchpin for nonprofits.

The landscape of major gifts is distinct. Not just in terms of the large amounts donated, but the intricacies of the approach it necessitates. General appeals suffice for routine donations, but when it comes to major gifts, it’s all about personalized cultivation, solicitation, and stewardship.

From affluent individuals to corporate giants, and from benevolent foundations to trusts, the array of major gift donors is vast. Their reasons for donating large amounts can span from an emotional bond with the mission to financial considerations or the aspiration of leaving an indelible legacy. To effectively tap into these motivations, a structured and strategic approach is essential.

Elevate your major gifts program by delving deep into our comprehensive Major Fundraising Workbook. With insights, tools, and strategies, it’s your roadmap to nurturing significant relationships and securing transformative donations for your nonprofit.

Dive Deeper into Developing a Major Gifts Program: Download Our Free Workbook Now!

major gift fundraising plan template

Laying the Foundation for Developing a Major Gifts Program

Before embarking on a major gift development program, an organization needs to evaluate its readiness. This involves assessing the strength of its donor base, the clarity of its mission and goals, the availability of necessary resources and personnel, and the level of commitment from leadership.

For a major gifts program to be successful, buy-in and support from the organization’s board of directors and key stakeholders are essential. They need to understand and champion the value of major gift fundraising and be willing to play a role in donor cultivation, solicitation, and stewardship.

Creating a compelling case for support is a crucial element of developing a major gifts program strategic plan. The case for support must convey the organization’s mission, the impact of its work, and how major gifts can transform its capacity to deliver on its objectives. This requires a clear organizational vision, a strong narrative, and persuasive communication strategies that resonate with potential donors. The case for support serves as a vital tool for engaging and inspiring potential donors and for demonstrating the tangible difference their major gift can make.

Identifying Major Gift Prospects

The first step in developing a major gifts program is identifying potential donors within your existing network. By segmenting the donor database, nonprofits can isolate those supporters who have a history of giving at higher levels, those who’ve been consistently supportive over time, and those who demonstrate an affinity for the cause. Leveraging your nonprofit’s CRM (customer relationship management) system to track giving history, engagement, and other key data points is crucial in this process.

Beyond your existing database, prospect research and wealth screening can uncover potential major gift donors. Prospect research involves gathering and analyzing data on potential donors’ philanthropic behavior, personal backgrounds, and financial capacity to give. Wealth screening, a specific part of prospect research, focuses on an individual’s financial ability to make a major gift. This might involve researching publicly available information about a prospect’s real estate ownership, stock holdings, business affiliations, and other notable assets.

While financial capacity is important, it is equally essential to consider a potential donor’s affinity and engagement with your nonprofit. A donor who is deeply engaged and believes in the mission is more likely to consider making a major gift. Tracking past interactions, involvement in events, volunteer activities, and other expressions of support can provide important insights into a donor’s affinity for your organization.

Building Relationships with Prospects

Developing a successful major gifts program goes beyond identifying prospects; it involves crafting personalized strategies to cultivate relationships with these potential donors. This can include individual meetings, personalized communication about the organization’s activities and impact, and opportunities for the donor to experience firsthand the work their donation could support.

A significant part of building relationships with major gift prospects involves engaging donors through meaningful interactions. This could include regular updates on the organization’s work, personal invitations to events, opportunities to meet beneficiaries or the leadership team, or tailored communication that connects their interests and passions to your mission.

Hosting cultivation events, such as intimate dinners, guided tours, or special receptions, provide valuable opportunities to engage with potential major gift donors on a more personal level. These events can help donors feel connected to your organization, and give them a deeper understanding of the impact their gifts can make. Additionally, recognition opportunities – whether in publications, at events, or through naming opportunities – can also play a key role in cultivating major gift donors, demonstrating your organization’s gratitude and ensuring donors feel valued for their contributions.

Making the Ask: Soliciting Major Gifts

Asking for a major gift is a significant milestone in the donor relationship. It requires thorough preparation, including a clear understanding of the donor’s interests, giving capacity, and relationship history with your organization. Setting clear fundraising goals that align with the donor’s passions and your organization’s needs will not only help guide your ask but also ensure that your solicitation resonates with your donor’s philanthropic objectives.

When soliciting a major gift, it’s essential to tailor the ask to each donor’s interests and financial capacity. Use the insights you’ve gathered from your relationship-building and research efforts to propose a gift that aligns with their passions, while also addressing critical needs of your organization. The more a donor feels that their gift can make a meaningful difference in a cause they care about, the more likely they are to give. Want to effectively communicate your mission and engage potential donors? Download our free storytelling workbook companion to elevate your narrative.

It’s common to encounter challenges when soliciting major gifts. These may include apprehension about the size of the gift, questions about the impact of the donation, or concerns about public recognition. A key strategy for overcoming these challenges is being prepared to address concerns, provide additional information, and offer reassurance, while remaining respectful of the donor’s decisions and timeline.

Stewarding Major Gift Donors

Effective stewardship begins with expressing gratitude. Acknowledging major gift contributions promptly and sincerely helps donors feel appreciated. Personalized thank you notes, phone calls from organization leaders, or public recognition (when appropriate and with the donor’s consent) are all strategies that can be used to express gratitude.

Major gift donors typically want to know how their contribution has made a difference. Providing regular updates about the progress of projects funded by their gift, sharing stories about the individuals who have benefited from their support, or inviting them to see the impact of their gift firsthand can all play a role in demonstrating the value of their investment.

Engaging major gift donors in ongoing involvement with your organization is a key element of effective stewardship. This could include invitations to special events, opportunities to volunteer, periodic meetings with the leadership team, or inclusion in strategic discussions. The goal is to make the donor feel like a valued partner in the mission, rather than simply a source of funds. This helps maintain a long-term relationship, which may lead to future major gifts and ongoing advocacy for your organization.

Training and Empowering Fundraising Staff and Volunteers

Ensuring that your team is equipped with the skills, knowledge, and confidence to manage a major gifts program is essential. This can be achieved through ongoing professional development opportunities such as workshops, seminars, or industry conferences on major gift fundraising. These platforms offer insights on the latest strategies, techniques, and trends in major gift fundraising, allowing staff to continually enhance their skills and expertise.

Fundraising staff and volunteers should be trained in effective communication and solicitation skills to engage with potential major gift donors effectively. This includes understanding the nuances of donor communication, honing active listening skills, crafting persuasive proposals, and navigating conversations about money tactfully. Role-play exercises, training sessions, and mentorship programs can all be effective in honing these skills.

Developing a successful major gifts program requires a culture of philanthropy at all levels of the organization. This means fostering an environment where everyone – from the board of directors to the volunteers – understands the importance of philanthropy to the organization’s mission and is committed to supporting fundraising efforts. Regularly communicate the impact of philanthropy on your organization, recognize team members who contribute to fundraising success, and encourage everyone to play a role in supporting the fundraising process.

Addressing Common Challenges in Developing a Major Gifts Fundraising Program

Overcoming Donor Objections and Resistance

Objections and resistance are common in major gifts fundraising. Overcoming these challenges often involves patiently addressing donors’ concerns, providing them with additional information, or demonstrating the potential impact of their gift. It’s important to maintain open lines of communication and to be respectful of donors’ decisions and timelines.

Adapting to Changes in the Philanthropic Landscape

The philanthropic landscape is dynamic and constantly changing, influenced by economic trends, social issues, and donor preferences. Staying adaptable and flexible is key to addressing these challenges. Regularly review your strategies, stay informed about trends in philanthropy, and be ready to innovate and adapt your approaches as needed.

Maintaining Donor Confidentiality and Ethical Considerations

Donor confidentiality is a significant concern in major gifts fundraising, and it’s crucial to respect the privacy of your donors. Additionally, ethical considerations should be at the forefront of your major gifts program, ensuring that all fundraising activities align with the principles of honesty, transparency, and respect for donor intent. Regularly reviewing your policies, conducting ethics training for your team, and adhering to the fundraising guidelines set by organizations like the Association of Fundraising Professionals (AFP) can help maintain high ethical standards in your major gifts program.

The Long-Term Benefits of Major Gifts

Major gifts can significantly contribute to a nonprofit’s financial sustainability. These substantial contributions can be used to fund core programs, drive new initiatives, or build reserves, providing the organization with financial stability and allowing for strategic planning and investment.

Major gift donors are often prime candidates for planned giving. With a history of significant contributions and a deep connection to the organization, they may be inclined to leave a legacy through bequests or other forms of planned gifts. Developing a robust planned giving program alongside your major gifts program can thus ensure a steady stream of support for the long term.

Major gifts can also play a role in creating a legacy of philanthropy for the organization. A transformational major gift can set the stage for future philanthropy, inspire other donors, and signal a strong commitment to the organization’s mission. This legacy can attract further support, ensuring the nonprofit’s impact extends well into the future.

Fundraising Made Easy: Discover Templates to Skyrocket Your Campaign’s Success

  • Church Planting Prospectus Template

    £22.00
  • Global Schools Fundraising Proposal Template

    £22.00

Conclusion

Embarking on a major gifts journey is not merely about securing significant funding. It encompasses laying a strong foundation with board support, constructing a persuasive case for support, identifying and cultivating prospects, mastering the art of solicitation, and stewarding donors effectively. Additionally, equipping staff with adequate training, continuously evaluating progress, and proactively addressing challenges are pivotal. To simplify and enrich this journey, download our Major Fundraising Workbook. Paired with our free storytelling companion, these tools are indispensable for every nonprofit venturing into major gifts.

The long-term advantages of a major gifts program are profound. Beyond the immediate financial boost, it deepens donor relationships, ensures financial stability, and could be the lifeline nonprofits need. Not to mention, the potential transformative power of significant donations – it allows nonprofits to amplify their reach, impact, and truly make a dent in the communities they serve. So, taking the time and effort to cultivate a successful major gifts program could be the game-changer in propelling a nonprofit’s mission forward.

Leave a Reply